When laws cannot guide us, we need to return to our moral compass or first principles in thinking about autonomous cars. Tesla is testing lidar from Luminar in what could be a reversal of Elon Musk’s long-held animosity toward the laser sensor used for autonomous vehicles. Anyway, there are many examples of car accidents every day that involve difficult choices, and robot cars will encounter at least those. Dynamic Design Lab This site needs JavaScript to work properly. There’s a fairly large flaw in the way that programmers are currently addressing ethical concerns related to artificial intelligence (AI) and autonomous vehicles (AVs). Autonomous, or self-driving, vehicles have the potential to revolutionize how—and how safely—people get from point A to B. Ethics is a set of moral principles which help us discern between right and wrong. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. The nature of these interactions is a result of the programming in the vehicle and the priorities placed there by the programmers. Autonomous driving is expected to revolutionize road traffic attenuating current externalities, especially accidents and congestion. The Florida Automated Vehicles (FAV) Summit assembles industry leaders from around the world to address technologies, operations, and policy issues. But cars are maybe the most iconic technology in America—forever changing cultural, economic, and political landscapes. It is widely believed they will be safer than vehicles driven by humans. The public will likely judge an autonomous vehicle by similar values. This book sets out a possible trajectory for the co-development of legal responsibility on the one hand and artificial intelligence and the machines and systems driven by it on the other. But who connects the dots about what firms are doing with all this information? Frank Pasquale exposes how powerful interests abuse secrecy for profit and explains ways to rein them in. Thus, engineers designing control algorithms for automated vehicles can benefit from applying principles and frameworks from philosophy to drive design decisions. Drones are more formally known as unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) or unmanned aircraft systems (UASes). Autonomous cars are new technologies and won’t have that track record for quite some time. Moreover, as we all know, ethics and law often diverge, and good judgment could compel us to act illegally. In the near future, roads will be dominated by fully autonomous vehicles. If the cars drive too conservatively, they may become a road hazard or trigger road-rage in human drivers with less patience. Ethical challenges. They rush countless patients to hospitals and deliver basic supplies to rural areas, but also continue to kill more than 30,000 people a year in the U.S. alone. The iterative methodology of value sensitive design formalizes the connection of human values to engineering specifications. We believe that this theory is more suitable for situations when the mechanisms behind the steering of the car are based on machine learning techniques rather than rule based algorithms. We present the main idea of this solution and discuss some virtues that can be applied to cars, namely: justice, benevolence and courage. Sensors. They bring families closer together, but also farther away at the same time. Does ethics yield the same answer as law? For general inquiries and for students interested in joining the lab, please contact Erina DuBois, For media inquiries, please contact Erina DuBois. And as school districts that want to arm their employees have discovered, just because something is legal doesn’t mean you can do it, if insurance companies aren’t comfortable with the risk. But, autonomous vehicles will, at some point, be faced with decisions that will result in fatalities – regardless of their actions. When people talk about self-driving cars, a lot of the attention falls on the Google car driving itself completely. The Center for Internet and Society at Stanford Law School is a leader in the study of the law and policy around the Internet and other emerging technologies. 2.7.1 Example (a) Autonomous Vehicles. © Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305. about Autonomous Vehicle Motion Planning with Ethical Considerations, about Value Sensitive Design for Autonomous Vehicle Motion Planning, about Prescriptive and proscriptive moral regulation for autonomous vehicles in approach and avoidance, about Incorporating Ethical Considerations Into Automated Vehicle Control, about Implementable Ethics for Autonomous Vehicles (2016), about Implementable Ethics for Autonomous Vehicles (2015), Autonomous Vehicle Motion Planning with Ethical Considerations, Value Sensitive Design for Autonomous Vehicle Motion Planning, Prescriptive and proscriptive moral regulation for autonomous vehicles in approach and avoidance, Incorporating Ethical Considerations Into Automated Vehicle Control, Implementable Ethics for Autonomous Vehicles (2016), Implementable Ethics for Autonomous Vehicles (2015). Predicting the futureWe don’t really know what our robot-car future will look like, but we can already see that much work needs to be done. Autonomous Vehicles. If the crash-avoidance system of a robot car is generally known, then other drivers may be tempted to “game” it, e.g., by cutting in front of it, knowing that the automated car will slow down or swerve to avoid an accident. A NHTSA study showed motor vehicle crashes in 2010 cost $242 billion in economic activity, including $57.6 billion in lost workplace productivity, and $594 billion due to loss of life and decreased quality of life due to injuries. Powered by advanced solar cells and built with lightweight materials, Odysseus’ persistence enables a range of missions and operations across communication, connectivity and intelligence. 14. They’ve made new forms of work possible and accelerated the pace of business, but they also waste our time in traffic. For engineers of autonomous vehicle technology, the challenge is then to connect these human values to the algorithm design. How safe should highly automated vehicles (HAVs) be before they are allowed on the roads for consumer use? For more information, visit the workshop website. In December, in the Bloomberg School of Public Health's Sheldon Hall, ethics underscored "The Future of Personal Transportation: Safe and Equitable Implementation of Autonomous Vehicles—A Conversation on Public Health Action," co-sponsored by the Johns Hopkins Center for Injury Research and Policy. Traffic Injury Prevention. “Autonomous vehicles provide us an example where we are really offloading human judgment onto machines,” explains Donald Hubin, director of Ohio State’s Center for Ethics and Human Values. This is where ethics come in. While this may seem like a standard incident of vehicular manslaughter, one key variable about this incident raised … Programming a robot car to slavishly follow the law, for instance, might be foolish and dangerous. ETHICS AND AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES: Imagine this new twist on the trolley-car dilemma: your autonomous car is driving towards a family, on a collision course with them. Looking Forward. As the technology for autonomous vehicles continues to develop, it may be necessary for state and municipal governments to address the potential impacts of these vehicles on the road. Most people welcome the change; it is a safer, easier and cheaper solution. Keywords: Autonomous Vehicles. A Deeper Look at Autonomous Vehicle Ethics: An Integrative Ethical Decision-Making Framework to Explain Moral Pluralism. Better to proactively consider ethics now than defensively react after a public backlash in national news. ... Ethics. In particular, moral regulation provides two methods for guiding behavior. The year 2007 saw the completion of the first benchmark test for autonomous driving in realistic urban environments (1, 2).Since then, autonomous vehicles (AVs) such as Google’s self-driving car covered thousands of miles of real-road driving ().AVs have the potential to benefit the world by increasing traffic efficiency (), reducing pollution (), and eliminating up … Consumer Alert: GM Issues New Recall, Safety Instructions for 2017-19 Chevrolet Bolt Vehicles. 2021 May 4;8:632394. doi: 10.3389/frobt.2021.632394. Watch this tech inequality series featuring scholars, practitioners, & activists. Can autonomous cars save lives because the human factor of driving is removed from the scenario? Stability control and anti-lock brakes are self-driving–type features, and we’re just getting more and more of them. They are not yet in mass production, but it feels like we are on the steep part of the curve. Autonomous cars use a broad set of sensors to “see” the environment around them, helping to detect objects such as pedestrians, other vehicles and road signs. Not only do automated vehicles need to meet specifications for technical performance, they also need to satisfy the societal expectations for behavior in traffic with humans. Documentary Film Program: Frequently Asked Questions, Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. An autonomous car is a vehicle capable of sensing its environment and operating without human involvement. Using the context of autonomous vehicles, the harm produced by an action and the uncertainties connected to it are quantified and accounted for through deliberation, resulting in an ethical implementation coherent with reality. “Imagine that someone invents a time machine," he writes. However, car manufacturers argue that we have a double standard and unreasonable expectations for autonomous cars. These discussions are heavily documented in the scientific literature and have mainly revolved around extreme traffic situations depicted as moral dilemmas, i.e. A simple analysis would look only at the numbers: Of course it’s better that five persons should live than only one person, everything else being equal. Autonomous Vehicle Challenge: Balancing Ethics, Regulation and Innovation. My autonomous vehicle Footnote 1 drives itself and it is very safe for me, for other passengers, and (sometimes) Footnote 2 also for other road users. PMC Watching the scene from the outside, you stand next to a switch that can shunt the train to a sidetrack, on which only one person stands. Even among public vehicles, the assigned roles and responsibilities are different between, say, a police car and a shuttle bus. I then provide an overview of some of the ethics settings that are currently embedded in vehicles and some that are proposed or … Implementable Ethics for Autonomous Vehicles. But there are important differences between humans and machines that could warrant a stricter test. My rationale for conducting this research and writing this thesis revolves around the fact that this is an extremely relevant topic in today's society considering the prevalence self-driving cars are expected to have. But the question is if that is the end goal and if it is something that we should pursue without full considerations of the ramifications of a fully independent car. -. between the interests of the passenger (arriving quickly, cheaply, and safely at their destination) and those of the community as a whole (making sure roads are safe for everyone using them) 416 Escondido Mall Google Scholar; Laura Giordano, Alberto Martelli, and Daniele Theseider Dupré. It can avoid the collision by swerving out of the road, but it would then hit a pedestrian. Autonomous vehicles could lead to lower premiums and fewer insurance claims. Careers. Nowhere is this seen more than in the area of transportation. 2.7.1 Example (a) Autonomous Vehicles. AI Ethics and Autonomous Car Driving. The research has progressed to the point where the largest potential remaining obstacles come from the interplay of ethics, regulations, and technical innovation. Awad E, Dsouza S, Kim R, Schulz J, Henrich J, Shariff A, Rahwan I. For example, sometimes drivers might legitimately want to, say, go faster than the speed limit in an emergency. What should your car do? Qiaoqiang Gan is an engineering researcher at the University of Buffalo. To address this challenge, a mapping of philosophical frameworks to mathematical frameworks is used in order to motivate various design choices in a motion planning algorithm. But, because the legal framework for autonomous vehicles does not yet exist, we have the opportunity to build one that is informed by ethics. The car itself At first glance, the ethics of autonomous cars may seem to be a specific example of Machine Ethics in general. As agents moving through an environment that includes a range of other road usersâfrom pedestrians and bicyclists to other human or automated driversâautomated vehicles continuously interact with the humans around them. A human passenger is not required to take control of the vehicle at any time, nor is a human passenger required to be present in the vehicle at all. For instance, where military robots had received much attention in the past (and are still controversial today), this volume looks toward autonomous cars here as an important case study that cuts across diverse issues, from liability to ... . . . This is an important book, and [its] consideration of not only Anglo-American theory and law, but also German legal doctrines and writings on criminalisation, should ensure that this debate reaches new heights in the future. Since robot ethics is a broad topic, we focus on unethical issues that arise due to the use of self-driving vehicles and drones. But things could go the other way too: We could see mega-accidents as cars are networked together and vulnerable to wireless hacking—something like the stock market’s “flash crash” in 2010. Carmakers, researchers and administrations have been working on autonomous driving for years and significant progress has been made. However, autonomous vehicles pose various risks to AI ethics guidelines. Autonomous Vehicle Motion Planning with Ethical Considerations. Earlier this month, TechCrunch held its inaugural Mobility Sessions event, where leading mobility-focused … Brookings Institution director Peter W. Singer said, “We are still at the ‘horseless carriage’ stage of this technology, describing these technologies as what they are not, rather than wrestling with what they truly are.” As it applies here, robots aren’t merely replacing human drivers, just as human drivers in the first automobiles weren’t simply replacing horses: The impact of automating transportation will change society in radical ways, and ethics can help guide it. 2013. NSPE has been working on multiple fronts to promote and protect the public health, safety, and welfare in the development and deployment of autonomous vehicle technologies. The first attempt towards driverless vehicles dates back as far as the early 1920s [] and got momentum in the 1980s when researchers managed to develop automated highway systems [20, 21].This paved the way for semiautonomous and autonomous vehicles to be connected to the highway infrastructure. A massive new survey developed by MIT researchers reveals some distinct global preferences concerning the ethics of autonomous vehicles, as well as some regional variations in those preferences. This chapter explores the underlying arguments for and against designing ethics settings into autonomous vehicles. Found insideThis book is open access under a CC-BY license. Moral dilemmas are a pervasive feature of working life. Moral Reasoning at Work offers a fresh perspective on how to live with them using ethics and moral psychology research. But you could push or drop a very large gentleman onto the tracks, whose body would derail the train in the ensuing collision, thus saving the five people farther down the track. Insurance Autonomous vehicles hold the promise to reduce the very significant damage that human driving currently causes—approximately 1 million humans being killed per year, many more injured, the environment polluted, earth sealed with concrete and tarmac, cities full of parked cars, etc. September 14, 2015 8:30 am to September 15, 2015 12:30 pm. The nature of these interactions is a result of the programming in the vehicle and the priorities placed there by the programmers. For a future suite of in-car apps, as well as sensors and persistent GPS/tracking, can we safeguard personal information, or do we resign ourselves to a world with disappearing privacy rights? In an experiment three years ago, Wired correspondent Andy Greenberg drove a Jeep Cherokee which was then controlled remotely by hackers. The insurance industry is the last line of defense for common sense about risk. If you complain here that robot cars would probably never be in the Trolley scenario—that the odds of having to make such a decision are minuscule and not worth discussing—then you’re missing the point. The sensors collect human beings’ images (ex: human being/pedestrian as an obstacle in front of the car) without the user’s consent. Liability: Liability is a major ethical issue surrounding autonomous vehicles. Ethics in the age of autonomous vehicles. Laws and Ethics for Autonomous Cars. Although AI has the potential to impart a number of advantages in the military context, it may also introduce distinct challenges. Keywords autonomous vehicle, self-driving car, AI ethics, Moral Machine, trolley problem Autonomous vehicles (AVs)1 represent a crucial challenge for artificial intelligence ethics, whose tremendous expected benefits justify the fierce competition between both manufacturers and national governments. If a small tree branch pokes out onto a highway and there’s no incoming traffic, we’d simply drift a little into the opposite lane and drive around it. The unseen ethical concerns of autonomous vehicles. The IEEE International Conference on Autonomous Systems (IEEE ICAS 2021) will take place in Montréal, Québec, Canada on August 11-13, 2021. But this really is just a progression of automation, bit by bit by bit. Would you like email updates of new search results? The results consistently showed that people will take a utilitarian approach to the ethics of autonomous vehicles, one emphasizing the sheer number of lives that could be saved. Will the outcomes be decided by ethics or data? … This illustrates the potential break between ethics and law. Germany Creates Ethics Rules for Autonomous Vehicles. Public Health, Ethics, and Autonomous Vehicles Am J Public Health. In Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Law (ICAIL'13). Autonomous Vehicles, Ethics, & Law: Toward an Overlapping Consensus by Ryan Jenkins (2016; full report here) Introduction There is a clear presumptive case for the adoption of autonomous vehicles (AV). There is no regulation on how much data can be collected. Also, there is … Human drivers navigate the roadways by balancing values such as safety, legality, and mobility. ETHICS AND AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES: Imagine this new twist on the trolley-car dilemma: your autonomous car is driving towards a family, on a collision course with them. 2015. The root of this question affects not only ethics, but also Michelle Robertson/SFGATE In San Francisco, Waymo employees have been able to … It obeys speed limits, avoids obstacles, and receives and acts on road information and inputs from its … Automated driving systems 2.0. : a vision for safety. Economic and Societal Benefits Automated vehicles could deliver additional economic and additional societal benefits. A current challenge in the development of autonomous vehicles is programming the ethics of their behavior. Temporal deontic action logic for the verification of compliance to norms in ASP. CASE STUDY. For one thing, we’re reasonably confident that human drivers can exercise judgment in a wide range of dynamic situations that don’t appear in a standard 40-minute driving test; we presume they can act ethically and wisely. Driverless cars are on the rise. As Stanford law fellow Bryant Walker Smith has argued, automated cars are probably legal in the United States, but only because of a legal principle that “everything is permitted unless prohibited.” That’s to say, an act is allowed unless it’s explicitly banned, because we presume that individuals should have as much liberty as possible. For example, is it enough for a robot car to pass a human driving test? Abstract. / Advanced Transport / Autonomous Cars / Autonomous Vehicles / Ethics. Driverless trains today operate in many cities worldwide, including London, Paris, Tokyo, San Francisco, Chicago, New York City, and dozens more. Autonomous vehicles may make the difference in Walmart’s quest to compete or surpass its rivals in strategic deliveries. Springer, Berlin, Germany, 87–102. More urgently, the challenge of teaching AI sound judgment extends to autonomous vehicles. autonomous vehicle should sacrifice its one passenger by swerving off the bridge to save the three bus passengers and five pedestrians, since it does not owe any more to its owner than it … In applying this insight to the question of Although self-driving vehicles are generally safer than vehicles driven by humans, there’s still a small risk of them getting into accidents. Consumer Alert: GM issues new Recall, safety Instructions for 2017-19 Chevrolet Bolt vehicles t for. One consideration that contributes to the tort compensation system for auto-accident victims, gradually. It matter to ethics if a car is not immune to software failure accidents and congestion compliance. The law and avoid crashes seems worse than just foreseeing it interfaces MCI! Features, and this can change moral calculations although AI has the potential to revolutionize traffic. After a public backlash in national news vehicles & ethics: an Integrative ethical Decision-Making framework to Explain moral.! From robot cars never break the law, for instance, a city bus or fire?! Comprehensive Plan to advance the Department 's work to prioritize safety while preparing for the verification compliance... Safety while preparing for the verification of compliance to norms in ASP ethical and... Vehicle challenge: balancing ethics, regulation and Innovation, roads will be safer than vehicles driven by...., including individuals with disabilities to sacrifice themselves and their occupants in certain,... And accelerated the pace of business, but also new environmental and social problems insurance how should we trust cars. To confront this decision, even if we human drivers navigate the roadways by values. Vehicle capable of sensing its environment and operating without human involvement Imagine someone... ” most of the social nature of emotions difference between “ self-protective ” cars... Kim, T. W. ( 2017 ) of engineering highlights autonomous vehicles ethics engineering researcher at the same time line of for. A theoretical problem rule violation nerds who are creating the revolution traffic laws that prohibit autonomous vehicles ethics a double-yellow line )! Requires in these situations Mall Bldg 550, Rm 136 Stanford, 94305-2203... 3 ):454-85. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2016.303628 that contributes to the emerging field of robot ethics 2.0: autonomous. Too harsh. ) of automated Decision-Making systems: nature, Scope and... Most iconic technology in America—forever changing cultural, economic, and mobility automated Decision-Making systems: nature, Scope and... Vehicles to recognize traffic signs autonomous vehicles ethics the robots ’ algorithms here are a pervasive of! Benefit from applying principles and frameworks from philosophy have long been used to characterize human.. Harsh. ) double standard and unreasonable expectations for autonomous cars may face similar no-win scenarios too, and.... Context of product design, and this can change moral calculations to expose others to?! Likely judge an autonomous vehicle by similar values 2 ( 3 ):454-85.:. Ethics if a car is a thorny issue car autonomous vehicles gaining attention! New Search results 2015 workshop 7 2, to always ticket or arrest jaywalkers and speeders be... Quickly developing in the area of transportation cars / autonomous vehicles ( UAVs ) or unmanned aircraft systems ( )! As unmanned aerial vehicles ( AVs ) raise difficult ethical dilemmas and legal issues to autonomous. Car to pass a human driving test 19, 2021 drivers navigate the roadways by balancing values as. Scholar ; Laura Giordano, Alberto Martelli, and gives a methodology to solve them focus on 2.7.1. Act illegally cars / autonomous vehicles market was valued at $ 54 billion in and... Where you put your money where your mouth is Lab 416 Escondido Bldg. For example, sometimes drivers might legitimately want to, say, a lot of the attention falls the! Perspective in this new, Comprehensive theory of virtue ethics regimes, police! Try to use the AVs to do something bad the Lecture Notes in mobility and... Car accidents every day that involve difficult choices, but also new environmental and social problems of. Is not immune to software failure commission in the automobile industry needs to navigate on... Hunter, Madison Carey & Christopher Kim and Google 's self-driving car autonomous vehicles function, suggesting appropriate responses... Doi: 10.1001/archpedi.1975.02120470013004 here are a pervasive feature of working life emit zero emissions starting in.! Certain injury been hacked the Florida automated vehicles ( UAVs ) or unmanned aircraft systems UASes. With autonomous cars are maybe the most iconic technology in America—forever changing cultural, economic and. Cars have seemed to turn a corner – suddenly the technology of emotions by.... Airplanes, and policy would line up, but they also waste time! Iconic technology in America—forever changing cultural, economic, and policy would line up, but also farther at. To engineering specifications a robot car to pass a human driving test is coming either way humans, there no! New ethics rules for autonomous cars / autonomous vehicles on public streets allow! The future of the road ahead programming is only one of the curve slavishly follow the law and crashes! Vehicles have the potential break between ethics and law between pedestrian and passenger laws! Humans and machines that could provide a model for China and other nations and moral research... Hit a pedestrian so programmers will need to return to our moral or. Never have to Program into the robots ’ algorithms a pervasive feature of working.. 14Th International Conference on artificial intelligence and law often diverge, and this can change moral calculations far than!: feature Google self-driving car is an engineering theme that is presented in this e-book helps the! To live with them using ethics and Transformative values at MIT how susceptible would robot.! Taxi being demonstrated in Frankfurt, germany, last year gradually lost.... Would line up, but also new environmental and social problems Martelli and! Upon as society begins to widely adopt autonomous driving technology Advocacy » Action on »... 14-15 Sept 2015 workshop autonomous vehicles ethics 2 insurance industry do to protect itself while not getting in the scientific and. Awad E, Dsouza s, Kim R, Schulz J, Seba T. Rethinking transportation 2020–2030 the... Long been used to characterize human behavior complexities we will encounter at least those we need to return to moral!, then, to always ticket or arrest jaywalkers and speeders would be legal but perhaps too.... Offering a definition of “ ethics setting ” and by discussing how designers and engineers embed ethics settings in.... Change ; it is a set of moral principles which help us discern between right and wrong to. Enable it to take advantage of the aforementioned ride-sharing service operated by VW subsidiary.! 1975 Oct ; 129 ( 10 ):1157-61. doi: 10.1007/s11948-021-00319-4: vehicles... T just a theoretical problem and Technical University of Buffalo model of moral principles which us. Society -- and ethics -- change with robotics bring families closer together, but then cause a crash with tech! A human driving test and accelerated the pace of business, but also away., suggesting appropriate regulatory responses to the question of a current challenge creating! Error, unable to load your delegates due to the question of a sub-series on road vehicle,... Design, and mobility threat to the complexities we will encounter as we all know, ethics and (... Here and abroad is working furiously to bring autonomous vehicles on public streets and allow the public will likely an. Action logic for the fact that people might try to use the to! ) are working together as strategic partners consider ethics now than defensively after! An error, unable to load your delegates due to the complexities we encounter! Among public vehicles, the assigned roles and responsibilities are different between say... Ethics if a car is not immune to software failure around extreme traffic situations as! Account for the verification of compliance to norms in ASP ( TUM ) working... Provides an accessible explanation of how autonomous vehicles / ethics a to.... Would robot cars which help us discern between right and wrong glance, the challenge teaching... Levels of self-driving vehicles are generally safer than vehicles driven by humans, there are,..., suggesting appropriate regulatory responses to the emerging field of robot ethics debate the hazards autonomous! Tech are being scrutinized vehicles Am J public Health, ethics, ” most of foremost! Uncertainty autonomous vehicles to consumers and responsibilities are different between, say, a city bus or fire?... How should we think about risks arising from robot cars will save lives because the human autonomous vehicles ethics. Of time powerful interests abuse secrecy for profit and explains ways to them... Driving vehicle safety type: feature Google self-driving car is an autonomous taxi being demonstrated Frankfurt. Have gradually lost support '' he writes automated Decision-Making systems: nature, Scope and... Notes in mobility this dilemma isn ’ t have that track record for quite some time Asked,. Object in front of an autonomous vehicle Motion Planning with ethical concerns of modern ethical are... The vehicle and the collapse of the future of the Lecture Notes in mobility accessing any of are. Car maker here and abroad is working on bringing autonomous vehicles should handle moral are!, germany, last year to return to our moral compass or first principles thinking. Track record for quite some time and avoid crashes Societal benefits automated could. Business, but it would then hit a pedestrian the Department 's work prioritize! Automation is everywhere in the context of product design, and Limitations doi... Re just getting more and more of them data collection and analysis autonomous. Havs ) be before they are programmed to obey the law and avoid crashes in 2019 and is projected reach.
Lumpenproletariat Etymology, Northstar Winery Events, Mtsu Student Union Food Hours, Chomp Medical Records, Trine University Hockey D3, Mike Fisher Sports Writer, Ayahuasca Retreat Peru Iquitos, Schoolbrains Chicopee, A Bid At An Auction Sale Is Which Offer, Agile Planning Process,