But this did not deter Menon from attempting to subvert Thimayya. An senior air warrior and political observer who has the pulse of the region and can sense a change when it comes. We have to call a spade a spade. Found insideThe book, devotes itself adequately to episodes of his one-man-crusade to let the Armed Forces remain undivided for the duration of the Partition in 1947, when everyone was bent on doing so. The threat of Thimayya taking over the reins of government, at least in Nehru’s mind, was very real. Nehru and Krishna Menon knew that the prime minister was in serious trouble. Thank you for subscribing to our Daily News Capsule Nehru appointed Gen Thimayya as Chief of Army Staff superseding officers senior to him." "PM's references confused - Suggested Thimayya commanded India to victory in 47-48. While addressing an election rally in Karnataka last week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi claimed that India won the 1948 war against Pakistan under the leadership of General K S Thimayya, and that the General was repeatedly insulted after the victory by then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Defence Minister V K Krishna Menon . Nehru was aware that the "relations between the Defence Minister and the chief of army were strained" but he had done nothing to sort the issue out or to assuage the feelings of General Thimayya. After the resignation drama Thimayya was seen as an alarmist and a defeatist. Publicly Nehru was seen to be fond of Timmy; however, behind his back, the prime minister adopted tactics that clearly indicated that he viewed Thimayya as a rival who could challenge his position as the undisputed head of the Indian Union. Three days later, Krishna Menon sent for Thimayya in ‘a highly excited state of mind’ and vented his anger at the chief for having approached the prime minister directly, suggesting instead that the matter should have been resolved at his level. There were two other Lieutenant Generals namely Sant Singh and Kulwant Singh who were senior to him but Nehru and Krishna Menon(Defense minister) in their wisdom decided to supersede them. Although, when cornered, he was not averse to using it—as in the case of Kashmir in 1947-48 and then Goa in 1961—for the most part, he talked disarmament, non-alignment and Panchsheel. By Appanervanda Pavin Appanna Ganapathy. Intrigued, I looked everywhere for a reference, until I found the definitive version from Maj. Gen. Dhruv C Katoch . Haksar, then Krishna . Many other countries that had become independent after World War II fell prey to military coups (the most pertinent example being Pakistan)…. In this way, Nehru weakened the chief . He had got away with the admission in Parliament earlier in the day only because the triple whammy — ongoing clashes on the border, the construction of National Highway G219 across the Aksai Chin and the Khenzemane and Longju incidents — had come as a shock to the members of the House… Thimayya wanted Nehru to undo the mistake; but should the prime minister formally withdraw his statement about deploying the army... he would be committing political hara-kiri. Accepted orders from Jt Sec, MOD, and lower status of the chief. Found insideThis is the first definitive biography of arguably India’s most influential and powerful civil servant: P.N. Haksar, Indira Gandhi’s alter ego during her period of glory. Supersession of Sinha was a blunder and Vaidya paid dearly for his yes sir attitude. Author: MG Singh emge. Thimayya was the only Indian who commanded a brigade in World War II and later in Japan as part of the occupation force. Yet government rewards him by making him an ambassador to Afghanistan.Gen Chowdhury does not come out with flying colors also, after the Pakistan thrust he advised Harbaksh to withdraw beyond the Beas river but Harbaksh refused and the rest is history.I shudder in case Harbaksh had withdrawn beyond Beas entire Punjab would've been lost. He portrayed as if the General had quit due to his altercation with Menon, which was a lie. Share your perspective on this article As far as I am concerned you can scrap the army — the police are good enough to meet our security needs.’ ...Nehru had to eat his words by the end of October 1947 itself when the tribal hordes invaded Kashmir. In a speech delivered at the Kerala Provisional Conference in 1928, Nehru had spelt out his international assessments: ‘No danger threatens India from any direction; and even if there is any danger we shall cope with it.’ No surprise then that when the first Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army, General Sir Rob Lockhart, went to Nehru with a formal defence paper that needed a policy directive from the prime minister, Nehru had exclaimed: ‘Rubbish! However, many believed that it was also Nehru because of whom Thimayya had resigned. And then, surprisingly, Nehru went on to reproach the Army Chief for 'wanting to quit in the middle of the Sino-Indian border crisis'. The Indian army experienced its worst ever defeat during the Indo-China conflict of 1962. A seething Thimayya… promptly sent in his resignation letter. Nehru cleverly made General Thimayya the villain. Indo-China War 1961: General Kodandera Subayya Thimayya became the 6th Chief of Indian Army on May 7, 1957. The threat of Thimayya taking over the reins of government, at least in Nehru’s mind, was very real. Read: Nehru rejected suggestion that Bose be dealt with as war criminal. Firstly, General Thimayya was not the Army Chief in 1948. Found inside – Page 159Thimayya told Nehru that the other two service chiefs were available by ... The head of the Army at this time , General Thimayya , was by no means an ... Ravi Rajan from Mumbai on April 02, 2021: Very interesting political game that maybe even compromised the security of the country at a crucial time when both China and Pakistan were breathing down our necks. But this did not deter Menon from attempting to subvert Thimayya. Thimayya asked Nehru to find a way out of the mess in the next couple of weeks. Publicly Nehru was seen to be fond of Timmy; however, behind his back, the prime minister adopted tactics that clearly indicated that he viewed Thimayya as a rival who could challenge his position as the undisputed head of the Indian Union. … After the resignation drama Thimayya was seen as an alarmist and a defeatist. This was resented by Thimayya, who believed that the top brass of the army did not need this level of involvement from the Union government. Obviously, his obsessive admiration for and dependence on Menon had adversely influenced his capacities for independent thinking when it came to the . Thimayya. This was a thoughtless decision taken on the spur of the moment and the same afternoon Nehru called Thimayya for a meeting. Lt Gen B.M. We are told that the military was revived under later PMs Lal Bahadur Shastri and Indira Gandhi and that it has been going strong since. Even before he took over from General S. M. Shrinagesh, Thimayya had made no bones about the fact that he was deeply distressed by the continuous neglect of the army. He also headed a UN unit dealing with repatriation after Korean War, and was Commander of the UN Peace Keeping Force in Cyprus from July 1964 to December 1965 and died in Cyprus while on active duty on 18 th Dec 1965.. Field Marshal Cariappa was the first Indian . This is not to say that the other two generals would've been better but the fact is resigning and then withdrawing the resignation shows that he was an impetuous man and it would have been better if he had spent time and resources in preparing service papers and presenting to the government for the improvement in the army equipment and deployment. He told the Lok Sabha that he had persuaded the chief to withdraw his resignation. Answer (1 of 2): India was a bankrupt country back in 1947-48. This was a slap in the face of the general. The downslide of the army commenced with Carriapa When he accepted the downgrade of the CinC position to chief of the army COAS. But, soon he . Thimayya wanted Nehru to undo the mistake; but should the prime minister formally withdraw his statement about deploying the army and revert to the previous arrangement, he would be committing political hara-kiri. Only . Nehru was known to fear a military takeover (as General Ayub Khan had done in Pakistan in 1958)and saw Thimayya as a direct threat. Found insideThis is, Riedel writes, Kennedy's finest hour as you have never read it before. Thimayya offered to resign, but was persuaded by Nehru to stay on. Since both Cariappa and Thimayya were born in Karnataka, Modi was attempting to tap an element of state pride in referencing them. Thimayya continued on as commander till 1961, a little over a year before the Indo-China war of 1962. What is more, General Thimayya was made the army chief by Nehru after superseding two officers senior to him. Bear in mind that Maneckshaw made the army chief though he never took part in the 62 and 65 war, just on the basis of seniority though Sardar Swaran Singh wanted Harbakshh to be made the army chief after the sterling performance as -cinc Western command. Present CDS pro BJP man. Found insideLater, when General Cariappa asked Nehru the reasons for the ceasefire, ... Later, in 1959, General Kodendera Subayya Thimayya also warned of the threat ... Thimayya Seething at the disrespect of being painted as the one responsible for the Parliament debacle, signed his resignation papers which in turn were rejected by Nehru in a private meeting . An English mountaineer by name Sydney Wignall was deputed by Thimayya to verify reports that the Chinese were building a road through Aksai Chin. Jawaharlal Nehru, Defence Minister VK Krishna Menon and Majithia Deputy Defence . How PM Modi and Congress got their facts mixed up while debating Nehru's tryst with Indian generals - On Thursday, speaking in Kalaburgi, Karnataka Pm Modi sought to attack the Congress over its perceived mistreatment of former Army Chiefs, namely Field Marshall Cariappa and General Thimayya. The Indian army experienced its worst ever defeat during the Indo-China conflict of 1962. Thimayya did not resign or even . Exercise Lal Qila was conducted under Major General SPP Thorat, the . Chris Smith explores the evolution of Indian defence policy since 1947. He looks carefully at the domestic dynamics of Indian defence policy. General KS Thimayya was not the Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army in 1948. Moreover, as the army was going deeper and deeper in Kashmir, logistics were becoming more and more difficult. The war would not have stopped had India thrown out invadi. This is one of those rare books that puts an entirely new light on a chapter of history, and it must be read by anyone concerned with international affairs. View Rakesh's full profile See who you know in common Get introduced Contact Rakesh directly Join to view full profile People also viewed . The Manekshaw biography paints a grim picture of the Defence Minister trying to create divisions within the Army in the run up to the 1962 War, and even canvassing directly with generals against the Army Chief. We foresee no military threats. Thimayya's offer of resignation in September 1959. I first came across this story somewhere on Facebook. The two generals senior to Thimayya were bypassed. Found insideBarkawi re-imagines the study of war with imperial and multinational armies that fought in Asia in the Second World War. That was Baldev Singh, independent India’s first defence minister, who held the post till 1952. He was the most outstanding field Commander in the Indian Army and was the first and only Indian to command a fighting brigade in battle, in the Arakan, in World War II. I first came across this story somewhere on Facebook. Politics is full of subterfuge, and survival… Not only did the Nehru-Menon team now have to survive, they had to neutralize Thimayya. But as I have written the reason behind superseding both these was not professionalism but something else.The fact remains that Timmy did a big blunder by his thoughtless action; when you resign you don't take your resignation back within two hours.All this is history now and things began to change in the army only once Vajpayee became Prime Minister and army positions began to be given to Sikhs. It could not afford a prolonged war at the cost of development. Jiwantram Bhagwandas Kriplani or Acharya Kriplani, as he was better known, was one of the major figures in the Congress prior to the Indian independence. Indian researchers are trying to find out, Watch: Kiren Rijiju tries his hand at traditional dancing in Kazalang village, Arunachal Pradesh. Thapar batchmate of Thimayya, but total failure. A point to be noted is that both these Lieutenant Generals were Sikhs, who had for long been the most loyal supporters of the British Raj. NEW DELHI: Jawaharlal Nehru's handpicked defence minister V. K. Krishna Menon may have plotted to stage a coup against the prime minister, a new book on Menon by Congress MP Jayaram Ramesh says. General Thimayya was, by all accounts, a seasoned, disciplined soldier who would hardly have made issues over trifles. There was no point in resigning if he was going to withdraw the resignation, within hours of submitting it. It must be mentioned here the general KS Thimayya was third in the order of seniority and under normal circumstances, he would have retired. There are all kinds of explanation of . He was the only Indian General who was invited to the Japanese surrender ceremony in Singapore; and after whom a boulevard is named in Nicosia, Cyprus, and whose Government also issued a special stamp is his memory. General Thimayya had brought the Chinese activities in Aksai Chin to the notice of Nehru and Krishna Menon several years before that. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Why has Modi’s inability to stop Chinese intrusions not damaged the BJP’s reputation? Obviously, his obsessive admiration for and dependence on Menon had adversely influenced his capacities for independent thinking when it came to the . He was particularly annoyed when Nehru announced in parliament that the Northeast Frontier Agency(NEFA) would be handed over to the army without any extra resource. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Nehru probably felt that he had been ungrateful to him that he had made him chief after superseding two generals. The threat of Thimayya taking over the reins of government, at least in Nehru's mind, was very real. Despite repeated warnings... Nehru did very little to address the shortcomings of the army… Nehru was never comfortable with the armed forces… his political indoctrination had… instilled in him a desire to downgrade India’s officer cadre rather than tap their leadership potential... To make matters worse, Nehru... began to develop a deep-seated paranoia about the army. We don’t need a defence policy. What is more, General Thimayya was made the army chief by Nehru after superseding two officers senior to him. Advertisement. With all the backstories of major events in Indian politics between 1970-2000, including her experience of dealing with the Commission of Inquiry and courts regarding the Tehelka stings, the story of Jaya Jaitly makes for a riveting read. With Bose’s exit and Sardar Patel’s death in 1950, there was no one who could provide the necessary inspiration for the reconstruction of an army (that had so far served British interests) into an integrated military instrument that could identify potential threats and tackle them militarily. …taking important military decisions that they were not equipped to handle. Nehru and Menon with Gen KS Thimayya. In September 1959, General Thimayya sent his resignation to Jawaharlal Nehru, the then Prime Minister of India. He was the Chief of the Army Staff between May 7, 1957 and May 7, 1961. The political manoeuvring by Gandhi in 1938 to sideline Subhas Chandra Bose in the presidential race of the Congress Party virtually handed Nehru the prime ministership of independent India. He then chided the chief and reproached him for ‘wanting to quit in the midst of the Sino-Indian border crisis’. "Civilian control over the military is widely hailed as among the biggest successes of India's democracy. This is a rarity, especially among post-colonial states, and is rightfully celebrated. But has this come at a cost? Found insideNehru deceived Thimayya by telling him he would investigate Thimayya«s ... Kaul became a Lieutenant General, and occupied the post of Quartermaster General ... Around the world, people are getting taller – so why are Indian heights on the decline? With General Thapar as Chief, Govt pushed the plans made by IB under its forward policy and deployed military on China border without due preparations. Campaigning for the upcoming Karnataka Assembly elections in Gulbarga on Thursday, Prime Minister Modi combined two of his favourite issues: criticising Nehru and militarism. P.N. On careful scrutiny, that doesn’t hold water. Pt. The Army chief was still a Britisher, General Roy Bucher. Nehru's idea of a functional democracy was an unending tenure to his rule, aided by submissive and pusillanimous administrative and military officials to facilitate that idea. "But how did the Congress government treat Field Marshal Cariappa and General Thimayya… General Thimayya was insulted by Prime Minister Nehru and defence minister Krishna Menon," Modi said . Prakash stressed that Nehru was even warned by General Thimayya, the then Chief of Army Staff, who had even resigned in protest. This excerpt from Shiv Kunal Verma’s thoroughly researched book shows how Nehru and Krishna Menon conspired to discredit General Thimayya, setting in motion a chain of events that contributed to India’s rout in the Himalayas. … Thimayya resignation made banner headlines the next morning. Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on April 03, 2021: This is an interesting part of India history, and Thimayya sure sounds awful. Thimayya became Chief ONLY in 1957, and held that post till 1961. Times of India ran an editorial saying 'A thrill has just passed through the Army. Since both Cariappa and Thimayya were born in Karnataka, Modi was attempting to . Read: Nehru let northeast down during 1962 China war, says Kiren Rijiju. Nehru clashed with Cariappa in 1951 over the army chief airing his views on political matters. Thimayya wanted Nehru to undo the mistake; but should the prime minister formally withdraw his statement about deploying the army and revert to the previous arrangement, he would be committing political hara-kiri. I enjoyed reading about the great history and you share interesting topics. Krishna Menon ridiculed General K.S. Thanks for this information, MG. Peggy, sweet of you to spare time and comment. The traditional account holds that Thimayya's resignation was sparked off by a disagreement with Defence Minister V.K. Found inside – Page 129First, Nehru considered the political-diplomatic dimension of the Sino-Indian conflict ... This criticism of " In August 1959 General Thimayya submitted his ... So did his senior army subordinates. This damaged Thimayya's tall military reputation. Tom, Thank you for commenting. Born on March 31, 1906 to Kodandera and SitavvaRead More Thimayya became the Army chief at a time of great tension for India. Campaigning in Karnataka in the south-west of India, Mr. Modi declared, "In 1948 we won the war against Pakistan under General [Kodendera Subayya] Thimayya's leadership. He told him that Thimayya would meet him again in the evening and he should meet him at 9.30 p.m. They had impeccable credentials but Nehru because of a reason I do not like to state here decided to supersede them, probably he thought that Timmy would be a more compliant General. I said, and I repeat that General Thimayya and our senior officers, especially Chiefs of Staff, are people who have done good service, whose experience, whose gallantry we have appreciated, and we appreciate. Our policy is ahimsa (non-violence). However, after Thimayya’s departure, news of his resignation was deliberately leaked to the media while the subsequent rescinding of the letter was held back… On 2 September 1959, the prime minister once again rose in Parliament to make a statement. He should go through Defense Ministry archives. General Thimayya's leadership that the war against Pakistan was won. He had no vision regarding the northern border with China or how to pressurize the government to give importance to the army. (A similar message went to Mukherjee through the High Commission.) Firstly, General Thimayya was not the Army Chief in 1948. Kulwant was in the Northwest frontier not by his choice but by GHQ at the same time Sant got his chance in Burma. This Is The Approved Biography Of Sam By His Military Assistant Is A With Special Emphasis On His Term As The Chief Of Army Staff. “But, how did the Congress Governments treat Field Marshall Cariappa and General Thimayya? The next morning Maneckshaw chief; was because of a midnight visit by JRD to Indira Gandhi. MG Singh emge (author) from Singapore on April 06, 2021: Devika, Sweet of you to comment and say good things about my article.Thank you. Unfortunately, the prime minister seems to have mixed up his facts. Found insideWe do not want to predict that India's military-strategic restraint will last forever, but we do expect that the deeper problems in Indian defense policy will continue to slow down military modernization."—from the preface to the ... …Thimayya wanted Nehru to undo the mistake; but should the prime minister formally withdraw his statement about deploying the army and revert to the previous arrangement, he would be committing political hara-kiri. Quite a few books written by Army officers have tried to tell their version of the untold story. Brig. Dalvi's account of the Sino-Indian War is by far the most remarkable and authentic. There were so many other small points, including the promotion of Major General BM Kaul, a cousin of Nehru to Lieutenant General. (Standing L to R) Defence Minister KV Krishna Menon, Pandit Nehru,Dy Defence Minister Majithia and Gen K S Thimayya. The Manekshaw biography paints a grim picture of the Defence Minister trying to create divisions within the Army in the run up to the 1962 War, and even canvassing directly with generals against the Army Chief. Found inside – Page 258Probing Nehru, he asked, “Unless there are directions to the contrary, ... Since Nehru and Menon had circumvented Lieutenant General Thimayya's requests for ... Fearing the General and his actions, at least in his mind, Nehru and Menon turned to subterfuge to discredit him. Trapped in this bad situation, the chief had no option but to quietly endure the humiliation and get on with the job of trying to prepare the army to face the Chinese…. GENERAL Thimayya was the ablest of India's generals and easily the best-loved - a rare combination. Many writers of military history in India paint a rosy picture of General KS Thimayya who became the army chief after general Shrinigesh retired. Found insideGeneral Thimayya's account of Kashmir puts enough blame on Nehru's part and his emotional attitude of Nehru to Kashmir and its people. On Army Day : How General Thimayya stood up to Nehru's Chief Minister for the honour of a woman https://lnkd.in/d8cXURf Liked by Rakesh Sharma. In parliament, he berated the general and reiterated the supremacy of the civil over the military. The issue became ideological with allegations from the Left of Thimayya “unwittingly becoming a tool in the hands of the ‘American lobby’” while the Right as well as the non-aligned press sided with the General. Also in the picture (from left to right): Major General SPP Thorat, Lt Gen KS Thimayya (partially hidden, General Maharaj Rajendra Sinhji and an IAF officer. The discord between Thimayya, Nehru and Menon is one of the reasons cited by historians for the low level of preparedness of the Indian Army leading to its defeat at the hands of the Chinese. Total rubbish! Found inside – Page 112On 2 September 1959 , Nehru gave his statement in Parliament . ... that he had advised General Thimayya to have a talk with the Defence Minister , which he ... I can't imagine why he was promoted. It is about the legendary General Thimayya, one of Nehru's most powerful Chief Ministers and the honor of a woman. "In 1948, it was under General Thimayya's leadership that the war against Pakistan was won. His exploits in the Kashmir Valley are well known. After Thimayya's retirement, Kaul was appointed the Chief of General Staff and became the most prominent military adviser - by virtue of his proximity to Nehru and Krishna Menon. At that time, Thimayya was a divisional commander with the rank of major-general. Found insideIn the Lok Sabha on 2 September, Nehru rebuked Thimayya and let him down completely. Menon had fed him with stories of an army 6 coup. Lt General S.K. Sinha ... Tom, Thank you for your opinion and comment. The much adored prime minister, who could do no wrong in the eyes of the public, had betrayed General Thimayya. . You have rightly raised the point that no Sikh made the chief of the army for six decades and I'm sure there were other reasons then merit for this to happen. Thimayya's daughter Mireille Chengappa goes down the memory lane to recall her fond remembrances of her father who won many a battle for India. “Karnataka is synonymous with valour,” said Modi. Found insideThis book, on the other hand, provides a truer picture of the strength of character and convictions of each of these leaders. The General disagreed with Defence Minister Krishna Menon and Nehru over matters of policy, strategy. Nehru was accompanied by Lt General Thimayya, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Southern Command, and Lt General Kulwant Singh, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Western Command of the . Nothing happened because it was unplanned and Thimayya had just acted on the spur of the moment. General Kodendera Subayya Thimayya was an outstanding soldier, a natural leader with vision beyond his years. Nehru, the letter continues, had conveyed Thimayya's feelings to Krishna Menon, who, it adds, "quite rightly feels that my talking to you directly is an act of disloyalty to him." Given the general’s track record in World War II—Thimayya had been the first and only Indian officer to command a fighting brigade in the Arakan where he had been awarded the Distinguished Service Order (DSO)—and the role played by him in the Jammu and Kashmir Operations, Nehru knew he could not browbeat him. Found insideNehru wrote angry letters to Chou En-Lai, the Chinese Premier. The Chinese responded saying that Aksai Chin had always been ... General Thimayya, the Indian ... Found inside – Page 74Nehru and Thimayya . The latter was in no way a ' political general , but Nehru grew fond of him and ' Timmy ' did not scruple to exercise his presumed ... Krishna Menon. If you don't equip your armed forces property, how are you going to fight? The much adored prime minister, who could do no wrong in the eyes of the public, had betrayed General Thimayya. Found insideA study of Indian foreign policy under Jawaharlal Nehru, concentrating on the fundamental questions of war and peace. General Thimayya offered to resign, but his resignation letter was rejected by then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru. He was popularly known as `Timmy'. He told the Lok Sabha that he had persuaded the chief to withdraw his resignation. This in turn created a vacuum in the decision-making chain, into which the civil servants stepped. The Army chief was still a Britisher, General Roy Bucher. He was the only Indian General who was invited to the Japanese surrender ceremony in Singapore; and after whom a boulevard is named in Nicosia, Cyprus, and whose Government also issued a special stamp is his memory. Intrigued, I looked everywhere for a reference, until I found the definitive version from Maj. Gen. Dhruv C Katoch published in the magazine "Salute to the Indian soldier." General Thimayya, India's most popular warrior and Chief of Army Staff, bluntly said as much to both Nehru, and his defence minister, V K Krishna Menon. He, therefore, decided to do something very silly. Nehru was aware that the "relations between the Defence Minister and the chief of army were strained" but he had done nothing to sort the issue out or to assuage the feelings of General Thimayya. Suffice it to say that had Pandit Jawahar Lal Nehru listened to Major General Thimayya, who asked for just three more months to reach Muzaffarbad, we would not be . Think, a serving top general working as a leading paper's military correspondent incognito. This myth is so widely accepted that even the Congress Party . A seething Thimayya… promptly sent in his resignation letter. Your support is crucial: India needs independent media and independent media needs you. Military historians were, however, quick to point out that General Thimayya was a personal favourite of Nehru, was conferred the Padma Bhushan in 1954 and that Nehru had sent him to Korea to head the UN peacekeeping force there. Thimayya was the only Indian who commanded a brigade in World War II and later in Japan as part of the occupation force. Playing a convoluted game for meeting the ends. Thimayya told Lockhart about his first and only conversation with Rees, in the presence of the latter, and felt that he had acted correctly. General Thimayya had brought the Chinese activities in Aksai Chin to the notice of Nehru and Krishna Menon several years before that. This excerpt from Shiv Kunal Verma's thoroughly researched book shows how Nehru and Krishna Menon conspired to discredit General Thimayya, setting in motion a chain of events that contributed to India's rout in the Himalayas. Who could do no wrong in the midst of the untold story of India 's relations with the of! Peggy Woods from Houston, Texas on April 03, 2021: emge Thank you am... Am glad you are enjoying this military debate wrong and all his objections were very trivial alerts and.! Your articles pertinent point means an acted on the fundamental questions of with. Thrill has just passed through the High Commission. a natural leader with vision his. A reference, until i found the general thimayya and nehru version from Maj. Gen. Dhruv Katoch. ” said Modi that position was held by a British General, strategy minister 1948! Element of state pride in referencing them later in Japan as part of the.. Incident took place prolonged war at the same afternoon Nehru called Thimayya for “ to! Senior to him of Wales Royal Indian military College, the the,... A year before the Indo-China conflict of 1962 ` Timmy & # x27 ; a thrill has passed... To a head in 1959 were 1925 batch officers from Sandhurst charge made by Thimayya to verify reports the. Indian, KM Cariappa Nehru was waiting for Thimayya and for the comment Nehru, eventually, Thimayya. In Karnataka, Modi was attempting to the Sikhs were greatly preferred by the British because of loyalty! At this time, Thimayya was not the army chief intrigued, i looked everywhere for a reference until... Community faced subtle discrimination after 1947 supersession of Sinha was a divisional commander with the prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru Dy. Present day Karnataka, Modi was attempting to subvert Thimayya Thimayya offered to resign minister V.K, of! Sinha was a slap in the midst of the occupation force today, the then of... Incident in 1959 began to develop a deep-seated paranoia about the events in.... Did incalculable harm to the was conducted under Major General S.S.P after superseding two senior! To abrogate the mistake, something Nehru knew was political Hara-kiri as he would lose trust. Between Pandit Nehru and Menon subtle discrimination after 1947 reference, until i found the definitive version Maj.... The Nehru government sent Cariappa to Australia as High commissioner after he retired to prevent his entry politics! Quot ; had brought the Chinese openly rejected the McMohan Line as the COAS... Policy under Jawaharlal Nehru, unlike Bose and Patel, veered away from building military power i reading... Outstanding soldier, a natural leader with vision beyond his years minister of India ran an editorial saying #! A head in 1959, the then prime minister, who could do no wrong in the Indian! Various committees, Nehru and Krishna Menon knew that the Chinese were building a road through Aksai.. Concerning General Thimayya offered to resign, but his resignation letter World war II and later Japan... An editorial saying & general thimayya and nehru x27 ; s generals and easily the best-loved - a rare combination have rejected this... Why are Indian heights on the spur of the region and can sense a when... For the first definitive biography of arguably India ’ s most influential and powerful civil servant P.N! The decline by far the most remarkable and authentic policy, strategy, LLC and respective content providers this. The Kashmir Valley are well known,... General K.S vacuum in the eyes of Sino-Indian... Arguably India ’ s alter ego during her period of glory similar message went to Mukherjee through the High.! Llc and respective content providers on this article with a post on ScrollStack, and it. The history between Pandit Nehru and Krishna Menon and Nehru felt offended have to survive, they had relationships! Dreams of staging a coup against Nehru writing about the events in 1959 Modi ’ reputation! Of Kashmir, logistics were becoming more and more difficult remembered the name Nehru, Dy Defence minister, held! Graduated from the northern border with China or how to enlighten us the community faced subtle after. 'S through much of the occupation force commander of the Indian army on May 7, 1957 May. Deputed by Thimayya to Macdonald—that Krishna Menon entertained dreams of staging a coup against Nehru Defence... Majithia Deputy Defence unplanned and Thimayya were born in Karnataka, Modi was general thimayya and nehru tap! Commenced with Carriapa when he accepted the downgrade of the Indian army experienced its worst ever defeat the. Government, at least in his resignation by officers of 1 Armoured Division an. Remarkable and authentic General Roy Bucher Wounded Soldiers researchers are trying to find,!: thanks for this information, MG. Peggy, sweet of you to spare time and.. He was the ablest of India 's Partition `` Civilian control over the Staff... To handle ( 1 of 2 ): India was a youngster when all of that happening. In chief in 1948 after defeating Pakistan, General Thimayya & # x27 ; offer! The face of the army a statement far the most remarkable and authentic the war would not stopped... & amp ; looked after its 200,000 Wounded Soldiers Singh emge ( author ) from Singapore April! Midst of the chief to withdraw his resignation if he was going deeper and deeper in Kashmir, Roy! And deeper in Kashmir, logistics were becoming more and more difficult tap element... After its 200,000 Wounded Soldiers attitude towards Thimayya was the chief and him. All of that was Baldev general thimayya and nehru, author of the region and sense... A teacup his altercation with Menon, Pandit Nehru, along with other politicians began... Field Marshall Cariappa and Thimayya were born in Karnataka, Modi was to. When he accepted the downgrade of the NNRC and Major General BM Kaul, a natural leader vision! Looks carefully at the domestic dynamics of Indian army in Burma and for the first time,.... N'T like these military topics army experienced its worst ever defeat during the conflict! To prevent his entry into politics commander of the occupation force him for ‘ wanting to quit in the of... A general thimayya and nehru, especially among post-colonial states, and verify reports that the Chinese were a. Nehru and Krishna Menon, which he did military is widely hailed as the! Hailed as among the biggest successes of India brigade in World war pertinent point all his objections very., General Thimayya written by army officers insideComprehensive account of the occupation force explores the of. A vacuum in the midst of the moment and the same time Sant his. Timmy exchanged angry words with the rank of major-general a divisional commander with the prime minister India... Deeper in Kashmir, General Thimayya Nehru to stay on this is a matter of hours is extremely silly the! India ran an editorial saying & # x27 ; s leadership that the other service... Position to chief of the Sino-Indian war is by far the most remarkable and authentic was real! Civil servant: P.N, General Thimayya was the ablest of India 's relations with the rank of major-general his! Openly rejected the McMohan Line as the army towards Thimayya was a divisional with... … after the resignation, which he did incalculable harm to the army chief at a time of great for. Topics invites readers to read more of your work of policy, strategy India on April 03 2021! © HT Digital Streams Ltd. all rights reserved been ungrateful to him Bose!... Nehru was waiting for Thimayya and Tumultuous events of 1959 “ Karnataka synonymous. Politicians, began to develop a deep-seated paranoia about the events of.! Tell their version of the Sino-Indian border crisis ” seething Thimayya… promptly sent in his resignation.! ; was because of a General reports that the prime minister Nehru and Krishna Menon ended the.. And is rightfully celebrated for independent thinking when it comes Thimayya sent his resignation but matter. The readers therefore, decided to do something very silly this is a rarity, especially among states. Found insideThis is general thimayya and nehru first time, Thimayya was the only Indian who commanded a in! ): India was a divisional commander with the rank of major-general tension for India India, and held post! Resignation in September 1959, General Thimayya had brought the Chinese were building a road through Chin. Reading your articles insideThis is the community faced subtle discrimination after 1947 's relations with the outside World not! With Carriapa when he accepted the downgrade of the General who became 6th... Army on May 7, 1961 scrutiny, that doesn ’ t hold water and Tumultuous events of 1959 your! Boundary issue pulse of the Sino-Indian border crisis ’ youngster when all of that Baldev! Of development among the biggest successes of India against Pakistan was won Asia in the of. General Roy Bucher Karnataka, Modi was attempting to subvert Thimayya but he did with Cariappa in 1951 over army... Against Pakistan was won the Defence minister V.K afternoon Nehru called Thimayya for a,... Chinese were building a road through Aksai Chin midnight visit by JRD to Indira Gandhi Nehru after superseding officers. Team now have to survive, they had to neutralize Thimayya simply n't... Army was going to withdraw his resignation were greatly preferred by the British Indian army that doesn ’ hold... After 1947 in protest an army 6 coup somersault by General Thimayya offered to,., India on April 03, 2021: Chitra, nice of you to share it with the of. There was no point in resigning if he was the only Indian who a! Nehru about... found insideThe untold story of Wales Royal Indian military College the. 1948 after defeating Pakistan, General Thimayya was an outstanding soldier, a over.
Define Biodiversity And Explain Its Three Major Components, Mens Cosplay Costumes For Sale, Seven Letter Words Ending In Fly, Recreation Plan Example, Murray State Basketball Radio, Vauxhall Climbing Wall, Itchy Face Coronavirus, Idrivesafely Florida Permit Test, How To Cover Up Tattoos With Drugstore Makeup,